Will this make you smell like fish?! Pcos L Carnitine Promix Nutrition Did You Know? Some people report a fishy smell after supplementing with L carnitine. This happens because certain gut bacteria convert carnitine to trimethylamine, a malodorous compound found in rotting fish. L Carnitine is Underrated. New Meta Review Reminds Us Why. Carnitine in the crosshairs: A fishy tale? Dr. Ronald Hoffman CUD Deficiency Primary Carnitine Deficiency